136689999 Dynamic-Auditor-2020-pvoa.pdf (66.26 kB)
Download file

Dynamic auditor competition and audit quality in the United States

Download (66.26 kB)
journal contribution
posted on 30.03.2021, 12:45 by Arum Choi, Jeong-Bon Kim, Yoonseok ZANGYoonseok ZANG

Regulators and audit market participants have concerned that less competitive audit market makes auditors to reduce the incentives to conduct high-quality audits. While a few studies examine the effect of competition in the U.S. local audit markets, they report conflicting evidence using the static Herfindahl index which is arguably noisy in capturing the intensity of competition. The purpose of this paper is to provide evidence on the effect of dynamic auditor competition in local audit markets on audit quality. For this purpose, we employ a measure to capture the dynamic nature of audit market competition: the proportion of clients switching auditors in the local market. Employing this measure, we find evidence suggesting a positive relation between auditor competition and audit quality and that the relation is stronger in large MSAs and for clients whose relative importance to audit office is smaller. This paper adds to the competition-audit quality literature by utilizing dynamic measures of audit market structure. In addition, the findings in this paper provide important evidence in response to the regulatory concerns that low competition is harmful to audit quality in a sense that it can cause auditor complacency and less rigorous audit procedures.


History

Publication Date

01/04/2020

Journal

Korean Accounting Review

Volume

45

Issue

2

Pages

31-75

ISSN

1229-3288

School

School of Accountancy

IRIS ID

136689999